What House Judiciary lawmakers said about impeachment in 1998 -- and in 2019

Posted Wednesday, 11 December 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Democratic Rep. Jerry Nadler in 2019 sounds a lot like Republican Rep. James Sensenbrenner did in 1998."Abuse of power" is what Nadler calls President Donald Trump's actions, declaring them impeachable.He "obstructed and abused power," is what Sensenbrenner said of President Bill Clinton's actions back then.The Wisconsin Republican now rails against Democrats as out to get Trump since his 2016 election."They haven't liked him from the beginning of his term," he says.Back in 1998, Nadler argued the same about the GOP and Clinton."Some members of the Republican majority ... have never accepted the results of the 1992 or 1996 elections," the New York Democrat said then. This time, the allegations sparking impeachment proceedings are obviously quite different. But it's worth noting another significant difference: which party's president is being impeached, and which party holds the gavel in the House.Five members of the House Judiciary Committee, the panel that voted to impeach Clinton, are still there: three Democrats -- Nadler, Sheila Jackson Lee of Texas and Zoe Lofgren of California -- and two Republicans -- Sensenbrenner and Steve Chabot of Ohio."When I was involved in this two decades ago, I really never dreamed that we'd see it again," Chabot told CNN during an interview in his Capitol Hill office, where he proudly displays a framed newspaper article from 1998 headlined "Moment in History." When that was written, Chabot was a leading Republican Judiciary Committee voice in favor of impeaching Clinton. Chabot was even one of the GOP managers presenting their case in the Senate trial.In that article about his efforts against Clinton, Chabot is quoted as saying he would not wish impeachment on his own worst enemy. "Well, it's bad not only for the individual who is being impeached, but it's bad for the country, because it really does divide us," Chabot elaborated during the CNN interview. "Sometimes it's necessary." Back then, he said that allowing Clinton's actions to go unpunished would "gravely damage the office of the president, our judicial system, and our country."It's what Democrats are now saying about Trump, almost to the word."They're saying it," Chabot conceded, "but I think the facts are very different."The substance is quite different. Trump allegedly abused his power by holding up aid and a White House meeting for an ally until its leader investigated his political opponent. Clinton allegedly abused his power by lying under oath about an affair with an intern.What is similar is the palpable solemnity of the moment.In 1998, Clinton's fellow Democrat Jackson Lee said she had come to a key hearing "bearing feelings of somberness and sadness,"During last week's hearing about Trump's conduct, she reminisced about her experience "during the 1990s impeachment, guided by facts, duty, to serve this nation."Judiciary Committee members who were there then and now say tensions are just as high. It plays out with gavel banging, interruptions and raised voices -- even if the political shoe is on the other foot.For example, in 1998, Nadler, a Democrat who is now chairman of the committee, argued strongly against partisan articles of impeachment."They must never be a narrowly voted impeachment or an impeachment substantially supported by one of our major political parties and largely opposed by the other. Such an impeachment would lack the legitimacy and produce divisiveness and bitterness in our politics for years to come," Nadler said then. On CNN's "State of the Union" last week, we asked Nadler whether, given the likelihood that Trump's impeachment will not have any GOP votes, that too will provide the divisiveness and bitterness he warned about 21 years ago. "No," he responded."It is the conduct of the President, who questions the patriotism of people who don't agree with him," Nadler replied.In 1998, Lofgren predicted that the GOP would suffer for impeaching Clinton."Those who are out to get the President, shame on you. But beware, next election the voters will be out to get you," the Democrat warned during an impeachment hearing.Again, the roles are reversed."If I were a Democrat, I'd be worried about it, and Zoe's comments back there could probably be coming out of the lips of a Republican right now," Chabot told CNN.Lofgren turned out to be right. Republicans did lose congressional seats in the 1998 elections, after impeaching Clinton. We won't know until next November if that bit ofhistory will repeat itself too.

Other articles published by CNN

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Rwanda has introduced robots as part of its fight against coronavirus.With 314 confirmed cases of the virus as of May 22, the East African country has enlisted the help of five anti-epidemic robots to battle the virus. The robots were donated by the ...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)It was a mouth-watering prospect for sports-starved fans everywhere. Four of the greatest athletes the world has ever known, on the golf course at the same time, offering us a glimpse of who they are when they aren't winning Major Championships and...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)A Texas community hit by terrible tragedy months ago came together over the weekend to celebrate a survivor's first birthday.Paul Gilbert Anchondo was two months old when his parents died shielding him from a shooter at an El Paso, Texas, Walmart on ...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Several members of the graduating class at The Lovett School in Atlanta, Georgia, have tested positive for Covid-19, according to a letter from the school."The school has been notified by several Class of 2020 families that their students have...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Just when you thought you'd learned how to spell Grimes and Elon Musk's unusual baby name, they've gone and changed it.Earlier this month, Tesla and SpaceX CEO Musk announced the birth of the baby boy in a post on Twitter, revealing his son was...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

In this weekly column "Cross Exam," Elie Honig, a CNN legal analyst and former federal and state prosecutor, gives his take on the latest legal news. Post your questions below. The views expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion on CNN. ...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

Rome (CNN)"The doctors were shocked. They said they had never seen anything like this," says Valentina Vigilante, recalling the terrifying day her 6-year-old son Nicolò was rushed into intensive care in Bergamo, northern Italy, as he struggled to...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Vanessa Bryant, wife of the late Kobe Bryant, shared a sweet moment this Memorial Day weekend -- a film of their baby daughter's first steps. In a video posted to Instagram, 11-month-old Capri stumbles across the room for the first time, into the...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)With two barren peaks that rise only about 170 feet above sea level, the now extinct Pūhāhonu volcano in the Northwestern Hawaii Islands doesn't look like much. This is especially true since in the same archipelago, Mauna Loa towers over every...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Photos and video of Memorial Day weekend celebrations across the US showed plenty of people going to the beach and gathering on boardwalks, but not a lot of people social distancing or wearing masks. From Florida to Indiana and across the country to ...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

Hong Kong (CNN Business)An online grocery business backed by Asia's richest man is expanding to hundreds of cities across India — a move widely seen as a challenge to Amazon (AMZN) and FlipKart.JioMart, the grocery platform owned by Mukesh Ambani's Jio ...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(Kaiser Health News)As states relax coronavirus restrictions, older adults are advised, in most cases, to keep sheltering in place. But for some, the burden of isolation and uncertainty is becoming hard to bear.This "stay at home awhile longer" advice...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)As warm weather sends people outdoors, some are encountering tenacious pests with no respect for social distance. Forget staying 6 feet apart: Ticks go for blood in the hardest-to-reach places on the human body. Many of those ticks are infected with ...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)At a glance, it may look like many Americans have long forgotten about the dangers of coronavirus.Crowds packed beaches in Florida, Maryland, Georgia, Virginia and Indiana over the weekend -- many venturing out without masks and others failing to...

Posted Monday, 25 May 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)At first glance, Shelley Allwang's cubicle looks just like any other office space.But alongside a pinboard full of tchotchkes and a photo of her dog, sits a story that reminds Allwang of the importance of her job, now more than ever. "The Boy and...