We're getting closer to stopping tech giants like Apple from abusing their power

Posted Wednesday, 15 May 2019 ‐ CNN

Sally Hubbard is director of strategic enforcement at the Open Markets Institute and a former assistant attorney general in the New York AG Antitrust Bureau. The opinions expressed in this commentary are her own.Of the big four tech giants, Facebook, Google and Amazon have been taking heat for abusing their market power, while Apple has been flying under the radar. That's because Apple's business model, unlike that of Facebook and Google, doesn't depend on closely tracking your data, and it has been more restrained than Amazon in the number of markets it muscles into. But thanks to a US Supreme Court decision on Monday, Apple is finally getting the attention it deserves. In Apple v. Pepper, the Court ruled that consumers have the right to sue Apple for charging them a 30% commission on every app sale. The plaintiffs are consumers who argued that Apple used its monopoly power to charge them more for their iPhone apps than they would have paid in a competitive market. Apple argued consumers can only sue the company that sets the retail price for antitrust damages. The Court ruled against Apple, saying the company's theory would "furnish monopolistic retailers with a how-to guide for evasion of the antitrust laws." The court did not rule that Apple is liable for monopolization — that issue was not before it — but it did clear the way for the case to proceed. The decision is a victory for consumers, who will at least get their day in court, but it's a loss for the Department of Justice's Antitrust Division, which shockingly had filed an amicus brief critical of the lower court's decision to allow the consumers' case to go forward. That a federal agency charged with enforcing antitrust laws supported limiting consumers' right to sue shows how far off the rails antitrust enforcement has gone. Several state attorneys general and my organization, the Open Markets Institute, had filed briefs in favor of the plaintiffs.The decision also highlights Apple's monopoly problems. Like other tech giants, Apple is extracting revenue on its own terms because it lacks competition. In 2018, the 30% so-called "Apple tax" brought in nearly $14 billion of revenue for Apple, based upon estimates by mobile app intelligence firm Sensor Tower. Why is Apple's cut called a tax? Just like the IRS, Apple sets the rate and consumers have to pay it. Taxpayers can't bargain with the IRS, nor can they choose a different IRS if they don't like the one they've got. iPhone users similarly don't have the choice to lawfully buy their apps elsewhere. On the other side of the app market, app developers also lack bargaining power against Apple. The Court noted the possibility that "app developers will also sue Apple on a monopsony theory." Monopsony means a single buyer has all power, and it's a huge problem in an economy where tech giants serve as gatekeepers that set the terms and conditions for suppliers and creators to do business. Ask any Amazon marketplace seller, for instance, if they can negotiate the fees they pay to Amazon — they'll think you're out of your mind. And like other tech giants, just because Apple created the iPhone doesn't mean it should be allowed to take over all markets that depend on its platform without competing fair and square. When AT&T had a monopoly over phone networks decades ago, it required consumers to rent AT&T phones to connect to its network. The federal government stepped in and allowed innovation and competition to flourish. Similarly, multiple app stores could compete for iPhone users' business by offering innovation and low prices. Just like AT&T in the past, today's tech giants have what I call platform privilege — the incentive and ability of platforms to prioritize their own products and services over competitors'. Spotify recently sued Apple in Europe for doing just this, arguing that Apple has leveraged its platform to distort competition in favor of Apple Music with unfair app store terms. Apple refutes Spotify's claims. As Apple plans to enter more and more markets, including streaming TV, credit cards and online gaming, Apple's playing the game and controlling it too will likely get worse. The Supreme Court's decision Monday may have only been a small step toward addressing Big Tech's monopoly problems, but it will at least give consumers the right to stand up and be heard in court — and it may even inspire US antitrust enforcers to finally take action.

Other articles published by CNN

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Hundreds of thousands of school students around the world walked out of class on Friday to urge their governments to take greater action in slashing greenhouse gas emissions. Climate protests are planned in more than 1600 towns in over 125 countries ...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

CNN national security analyst John Kirby, a retired rear admiral in the US Navy, was a spokesman for both the State and Defense Departments in the Obama administration. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)There's a major shake-up this morning on the world stage. Let's get right to that and what else you need to know to Get Up to Speed and Out the Door. (You can also get "5 Things You Need to Know Today" delivered to your inbox daily. ...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

Luke McGee is a senior producer at CNN based in London.London (CNN)Brexit has destroyed another British Prime Minister.Three years after voters in the UK mandated their government to take Britain out of the European Union, Theresa May's failure to do so...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)While "Medicare for all" quickly became one of the top policy issues of the 2020 race for the Democratic presidential nomination, polling doesn't show a clear preference for a government-run health care program over the current system.Many Americans ...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)"One man's food is another man's poison." - Lucretius (99-55 B.C.)Most people have this basic understanding of genetics: You inherit genes from your parents, and their DNA combines to create your unique genetic makeup. This can include more obvious ...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)England's rugby sevens players have a secret weapon, but to find it they have to dig deep.It lies at the end of a grueling fitness regime which involves recreating the state of utter exhaustion the body experiences in the "death zone," a term used...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Among the heavily trafficked streets of Atlanta, a massive urban food forest is growing to provide fresh produce for the public. But what exactly is a food forest?In the fight against food deserts -- low income areas that lack access to fresh, whole ...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Jayme Closs' relatives spent three months agonizing over the Wisconsin teenager's whereabouts before she escaped from the man who'd gunned down her parents and imprisoned her in a remote cabin. On Friday, they'll spend a few hours facing Jake...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Bullying is many things: teasing, name-calling, stereotyping, fighting, exclusion, spreading rumors, public shaming and aggressive intimidation. It can be in real life (IRL) or online. During the 2017-18 school year, 7 in 50 public high school...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Americans have struggled with the many food labels and their meanings for years. Sell by, best by and best if used by -- what are the differences? Now, the Food and Drug Administration wants to make it a little easier. In a new guidance issued...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

London (CNN Business)1. Oil watch: Investors will be keeping a close eye on oil Friday after it suffered its worst day since Christmas Eve on Thursday.After starting the day above $61, US oil prices nosedived nearly 6%...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

Hong Kong (CNN Business)Another US tech giant is distancing itself from Huawei. Microsoft (MSFT) has removed the Chinese company's laptops from its online store. A search on Friday for "Huawei" returned no results for any devices, and links to the latest ...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

London (CNN)UK Prime Minister Theresa May has announced her resignation, finally bowing to intense political pressure over the failure to deliver her signature policy -- Britain's withdrawal from the European Union.May said Friday she would quit as...

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Attorneys representing claims against Harvey Weinstein, his company and former associates have reached a $44 million settlement to resolve civil lawsuits over his alleged sexual misconduct.The attorneys told a Delaware bankruptcy judge Thursday they ...