The history lesson 2020 Democrats can't afford to ignore

Posted Thursday, 12 September 2019 ‐ CNN

Thomas Balcerski is author of "Bosom Friends: The Intimate World of James Buchanan and William Rufus King" (Oxford University Press). He tweets @tbalcerski. The opinions expressed (CNN)Once more, the upcoming Democratic debates will offer voters a chance to see the party's presidential hopefuls in action. Divisions over ideology and identity have defined the race: the liberals debate the moderates over policy questions, the Northeasterners quibble with the Midwesterners about attracting voters, and the young needle the old over who should lead. The one thing on which the Democratic field seems to agree is that their party fundamentally differs from the politics and policies of Donald Trump.By adopting a defeat-Trump-at-any-cost strategy, the Democrats have missed a key lesson from the past: being the party of opposition and the promoters of mere change will only carry you so far. The approach may yield electoral success in the short-term, but it fails to create lasting change and, worse still, does nothing to communicate an effective vision for the future of this country to the voting public. By not recognizing that their enemy is not so much Donald Trump as their own myopic commitment to defining themselves in opposition to him, Democrats risk the future of the country with their lack of vision.Here is where history can help. By studying the campaign messaging and strategies from prior presidential elections, the Democrats can help to clarify what has worked well and what has failed miserably in the past. As it turns out, the history of the Democratic Party is chock full of examples of both.During the Great Depression, the Democrats seized power under the charismatic leadership of Franklin Delano Roosevelt. In the election of 1932, Roosevelt ran less against the incumbent, Herbert Hoover, than he did for a program of visionary transformation of America. During the campaign, Hoover attempted to brand Roosevelt as a radical; rather than issuing a direct rebuttal to these attacks, FDR instead rejected the idea that the ongoing economic downturn could not be corrected. This did not prevent Roosevelt from drawing a contrast between his policy ideas and those of the incumbent: "Here is the difference between the President and myself," he declared, "I go on to pledge action to make things better." Dubbed the "New Deal," Roosevelt's vision effectively set the political agenda for a generation of American politics. Harry Truman looked to expand the reach of the New Deal with a "Fair Deal" that promised progress in the areas of civil rights, education, health care, welfare, and more. Although he did not fulfill all its stated aims, Truman set the tone for later presidents: Both John F. Kennedy's "New Frontier" and Lyndon Johnson's "Great Society" programs set forth the idea of a safer, more inclusive America that would be more humane to its citizens. These Democrats stood for a vision of America that included government as a partner and not simply against their opponents.In contrast, the Democratic Party of the mid-20th century faltered. Adlai Stevenson, a brilliant tactician and strategist, helped to formulate the "Domino Theory" as a way to stop the spread of communism around the world. But as the party's candidate in 1952, he could not present a coherent plan to end the unpopular Korean War. Dwight Eisenhower, a war hero, promised to do so and ran on the simple phrase "I Like Ike." He won in a landslide. In 1956, Stevenson was given a second chance and this time opted to run against Eisenhower's age (he was 66) and ill-health (he had suffered a heart attack). Once again, the American people decided that they liked Ike.The election of Richard Nixon in 1968 and the subsequent breakup of the New Deal coalition set the Democratic Party adrift. In time, Democratic hopefuls seemed to turn to the theme of "change" as the political answer to Republican rule. The candidacies of Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton respectively promised to bring "Leaders, for a Change" (1976) and "For People, for a Change" (1992). On the surface, they were charismatic young leaders in whom Americans felt comfortable placing their full faith.In retrospect, the change that they offered did not last. While in office, Carter turned against his own optimism for America's future and instead warned of a "malaise" afflicting the country. Clinton's bold vision for America was derailed by mismanagement (especially on health care reform) and his personal failings as a leader.As the 21st century began, the Democrats floundered. Al Gore ran on the concept of "Leadership for the New Millennium," but the legacy of Bill Clinton likely convinced voters to embrace the "compassionate conservatism" of George W. Bush instead. In 2004, John Kerry's vague promise of a "Stronger America" could not defeat Bush's continued promise of a "More Hopeful America."Yet once more, also in 2008, the Democrats chose a candidate who espoused "Hope" and "Change We Can Believe In." The country responded by overwhelmingly electing Barack Obama as the nation's first African American president. The electoral backlash of the 2010 midterms limited the party's vision once again and foretold some aspects of the rise of Donald Trump. In 2016, "I'm With Her" was not a strong enough vision for America's future to counter the more hardline message of "Make America Great Again." The Blue Wave of 2018 once more showed that some in the Democratic Party can present a better message to the American people than their Republican counterparts. Yet so far, in the 2020 presidential campaign, the party has continued to rely upon the idea of defeating Donald Trump as its most salient message. Americans should choose Democrats as the lesser of two evils, they seem to be saying. Jill Biden has practically said as much.This strategy has almost never worked in the long term, and it will almost certainly fail, as it did in the election of 2016, if voters do not like the party's candidate selected in 2020. Democrats -- both moderates and progressives -- should be wary.Whoever emerges as the Democratic candidate in 2020 would instead do well to remember the words of FDR, who as a candidate himself declared at a 1932 commencement speech: "The country needs and, unless I mistake its temper, the country demands bold, persistent experimentation. It is common sense to take a method and try it: If it fails, admit it frankly and try another. But above all, try something."The Democrats have been at their best when they lead change from an inclusive and bold vision for the future, one not predicated on defeating the current occupant of the Oval Office. They should look, as FDR once said, to try, rather than simply to oppose.

Other articles published by CNN

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

Washington (CNN)President Donald Trump on Sunday evening tweeted that the US has "reason to believe that we know" who is responsible for an attack on a Saudi Arabian oil field and the country is "locked and loaded depending on verification" following the ...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Thirty-five years after Live Aid rocked the world, a coalition of nonprofits, CEOs and government leaders is reviving a global effort to unite the world through music.Dubbed "Global Goal Live: The Possible Dream," the event, which is presented by...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

New York (CNN Business)As oil prices surged Sunday, President Donald Trump said he was authorizing the use of oil from the country's emergency reserve after Saturday's attack on Saudi Arabian oil facilities disrupted the global supply of crude.Trump, in...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)CP Crawford's been a Chicago White Sox fan for almost as long as he's been alive, but he'd never been to see them play -- until he turned 112.The supercentenarian was born in 1907, just seven years after the Sox moved to Chicago. He religiously...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)With 141 days until the Iowa caucuses and a record number of Democratic candidates, the 2020 election is in full swing. Every Sunday, I will outline the 5 BIG storylines you need to know to understand the...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

Samantha Vinograd is a CNN national security analyst. She served on President Barack Obama's National Security Council from 2009 to 2013 and at the Treasury Department under President George W. Bush. Follow her @sam_vinograd. The views expressed in this...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

Dennis Ross, former US envoy to the Middle East, is the Davidson distinguished fellow at the Washington Institute. David Makovsky, former senior adviser to the special envoy for Israeli-Palestinian negotiations, is the Ziegler distinguished fellow at The ...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)A Missouri woman is fighting to keep three monkeys she claims have provided her emotional support for years.Texanne McBride-Teahan may lose possession of the animals after a neighbor in Creve Coeur, a suburb of St. Louis, spotted one monkey outside...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Couples applying for marriage licenses in Virginia will no longer have to disclose their race, the state's attorney general said, after three couples said they were denied marriage licenses after declining to do so.Applicants will now be able to...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

Washington (CNN)Democratic presidential candidates Beto O'Rourke and Pete Buttigieg clashed Sunday over O'Rourke's direct comment about his proposed mandatory gun-buyback program of assault-style rifles. "Hell, yes, we're going to take your AR-15, your...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Here's what you need to know to Start Your Week Smart.(You can also get "5 Things You Need to Know Today" delivered to your inbox daily. You give us five minutes, and we give you five things you must know for your weekday, plus a...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

September 16, 2019After bringing you up to speed on a weekend attack on Saudi Arabian oil facilities, we're taking a look at the complicated relationship between the U.S. and Saudi Arabia. Afterward, our international coverage takes us to...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

Washington (CNN)Democratic Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar responded Sunday to criticism from the son of a victim of the 9/11 terror attacks over comments she made earlier this year.Omar was criticized by Nicholas Haros Jr., whose mother died in the World...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)The Tennessee Titans undoubtedly wanted to bring the fire for their home opener against the Indianapolis Colts. The team probably wasn't planning for actual flames to break out on the field. Shortly before the game began, the team's pyrotechnic...

Posted Sunday, 15 September 2019 ‐ CNN

Washington (CNN)A day after Secretary of State Mike Pompeo blamed Iran for the attack on Saudi oil facilities and argued there is "no evidence the attacks came from Yemen," a senior administration official briefed CNN on information to back up Pompeo's...