The EU is facing a serious crisis. It's funding the same people who wish to wreck it

Posted Saturday, 15 February 2020 ‐ CNN

London (CNN)For nearly four years, Brexit has masked the fact that the European Union is in trouble.The EU establishment is about to embark on years of deciding how the bloc can reform, refresh and ultimately reunite. One small snag: since Brexit, some Euroskeptic populists within the union have shifted from trying to leave the bloc to wanting to take it over and wreck it from within.The EU's populist problem neither starts nor ends with Brexit. One of the strangest facets of the European Union is that through its own bureaucracy, it has created the perfect environment for Euroskeptics to build support for an anti-EU agenda.Nigel Farage, leader of the Brexit party, said in the UK's final days of membership that Brexit, ironically, would not have happened without the legislative branch of the EU, the European Parliament. "To be honest, we used the wherewithal provided by the European Parliament to build a UK political movement."Farage could be referring to any number of goodies that await Members of the European Parliament on their election.Some time ago, the EU decided that it would be a good thing for MEPs to set up political groupings within the parliament. The idea: if you were a socialist in Spain, you could find your fellow socialists in Sweden or France and work as a bloc.This led to the formation of not only groups in the Parliament, but multi-national political parties outside of it. All of these organizations employ staff in Brussels and at home. They have their travel and living expenses paid for by the EU's budget. They can set up think tanks to research and promote their ideas, all on the EU's dollar.From Brussels' perspective, this is all well and good if those MEPs are working to strengthen the union. However, the EU's rules around funding are opaque and the system is open to abuse.For example, the $4,897 monthly "general expenditure allowance" is afforded to all 705 MEPs. While this money is supposed to be used for "parliamentary activities, such as office rent and management costs," MEPs do not have to submit receipts when claiming these expenses. "I can't give an example in the public or private sphere, where there is absolutely no financial management of what amounts to nearly €40 million per year in public money," says Nicholas Aiossa, deputy director of Transparency International EU.Few miscreants have ever been held to account. In 2017, far-right Marine Le Pen's French National Front was formally investigated with fraudulently using millions of EU dollars to fund national campaigns back home. The National Front denied the allegations. And in 2019, Farage's former party, UKIP, was forced to pay more than $250,000 back to the EU for similar reasons, but strenuously denied that any rules were broken. In both instances, these were Euroskeptic parties who would ultimately like to see the EU changed beyond recognition. Funding is only the start. The EU Parliament's proportional representation also means that far-right parties, squeezed out of power at a national level, have a shot at being elected, having a platform and making friends with like-minded populists across the continent. "The European Parliament has been a breeding ground for some of these movements," says Daniel Freund, a Green MEP from Germany.Freund explains that the far right are ruthlessly efficient at squeezing the most out of Brussels. "They are not always ideologically coherent and don't vote together but they can form political groups to increase things like staff allocation and speaking time in the Parliament."Speaking time matters. Speeches in the parliament are translated into every EU language. They often end up on social platforms. This puts Euroskeptic MEPs, some of whom would have struggled to get elected to local councils at home, in front of massive audiences.Being in the Parliament also allows populists to perform anti-EU stunts. Memorable incidents include the time that an Italian far-right MEP by the name of Gianluca Buonanno put on a mask of Angela Merkel and interrupted the then-European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker as he spoke in Parliament. Buonanno was protesting the EU's migration policy, making the point that rich countries like Germany inflict policy on poorer nations.Last year, Brexit party MEPs turned their backs during a performance of the EU anthem. The video provided the Euroskeptics with a viral hit for fans at home. And it's how this stuff plays at home that really matters."In the European Parliament they are noisy. But their capacity to influence legislation is close to zero," says Siegfried Muresan, vice chair of the European People's Party, the most powerful pan-European political group. While that might be true -- the far-right only accounts for around 10% of all MEPs -- their increased vote share over time has already influenced the domestic political agenda in a number of member states.Sara Hobolt, Professor of European Politics at the London School of Economics, explains that far-right parties have successfully exploited "more indirect ways of influence ... as mainstream parties across Europe have been seen to accommodate some of the positions of the radical right." She says that the most obvious example has been the mainstreaming of far-right ideas on immigration."The more of a threat the radical right is seen to be electorally, the greater the temptation for the center-right and even the center-left to seek to adopt some of the same rhetoric of these parties to win back voters."This is where we come back to European reform. While the parliament might have a huge pro-European majority, it's the political leaders of the member states (who form the European Council) who hold real power."The biggest threat to the EU is not far-right parties gaining in strength; the biggest threat to the EU is where pro-EU politicians become more Euroskeptic, due to lack of reforms over the EU's key institutions," says James F. Downes, a researcher at the Chinese University of Hong Kong.Without addressing "the democratic deficit in the EU Parliament and the technocratic nature of the European Commission," European reform could lead to less integration, as European populations tire Brussels. Downes adds, "this would lead to a more scaled-back economic version of the EU project and the political project of the EU becoming obsolete in the longer-term."While this might sound like tinkering, the implications of getting it wrong are huge for Europe. "Just because these parties have stopped talking about Brexit it doesn't mean they don't see something similar for their own countries in the long run," says Fabian Zuleeg, director of the European Policy Centre. "We have to be able to say what the EU is for and this is why the EU is better addressing these challenges than what we see at a national level."He has a point. While appetite for leaving the EU has declined recently across Europe, Euroskeptic populists continue to perform well in elections. If the European project continues to feed the populist beast, the domestic political scene across the continent could continue to fragment. "What can happen at the European level is dependent on how strong governments are at home," says Zuleeg.How does the EU fix this? Brussels has already outlined plans to make the EU feel less remote for Europeans, from hosting "citizens dialogue" events to an ambitious climate policy that produces jobs and gives real people real benefits. And throughout 2020-2022, the EU will discuss ideas for a way forward in its Conference on the Future of Europe.The idea was largely driven by French President Emmanuel Macron. However, eagle-eyed Europe watchers will know that while Macron plays a big role on the European stage, at home he is dogged by regular protests and inconsistent public approval.All of which brings us back to the great unknown of how much appetite there is for a more pro-European agenda.Rid of the troublesome UK, the EU can now get on with safeguarding its own future. The question is: How much damage has years of perceived inaction and muted responses to real concerns eroded affection for the project?If the EU fails to make a case for itself, it may discover that the rot at its core cannot be repaired. And as it tries to combat those who wish to wreck the project from within, it may find it's already been defeated in many of the key opening battles for the heart of the continent.

Other articles published by CNN

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

Zillow has long been known as the place to go when you're looking to buy a new home. It's famous for its Zestimate, which uses proprietary algorithms to estimate the current price of your house (or your neighbor's, if you're feeling nosy).But Zillow...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)A highway in Florida won't be keeping its name much longer after a county voted to change the name of a handful of "Dixie" highways to "Harriet Tubman Highway."Miami-Dade County commissioners unanimously approved plans Wednesday to rename portions...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)What's spreading faster than the coronavirus? In the US at least, racist and xenophobic attacks against anyone who looks Asian. Here's what you need to know to Get Up to Speed and Out the Door. (You can also get "5 Things You...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

Maseru, Lesotho (CNN)Lesotho's Prime Minister Thomas Thabane failed to show up in court Friday where he was due to be charged with murdering his former wife, police said. Lipolelo Thabane was killed outside her home in the capital Maseru just days before ...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Talk to anyone who has known John Lewis for any length of time and you'll eventually hear the story about him preaching to the chickens.It goes something like this: Lewis was a shy black kid with a stutter who was determined to be a preacher while...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

New York (CNN Business)A mother reaches into an envelope and pulls out her child's report card while her young son stands visibly anxious nearby. Report card season can be a nerve-wracking time for any student, but in this situation, the ...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Bullied at school for his dwarfism, 9-year-old Quaden Bayles sobs uncontrollably in the back of his mother's car -- saying to the camera: "Give me a knife, I want to kill myself."His mother, Yarraka Bayles, from the Australian state of Queensland,...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Older adults may have better success at losing weight if they do it with the help of intensive behavioral therapy from dietitians, a new study suggests.Intensive behavioral therapy for obesity, or IBTO, is a customized treatment...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)It was French maestro Zinedine Zidane who first inspired Lisa Zimouche to start kicking a football. The freestyler still remembers watching her hero lift the World Cup for France in 1998 and, from that moment, her heart was set. "I fell in love with ...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Authorities are still trying to piece together what happened to the two Idaho children who have been missing for five months. In that time, their mother re-married and fled to Hawaii with her husband once police began investigating the...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Scientists studying the remarkably well-preserved remains of an Ice Age bird have identified the specimen as a horned lark.Buried and frozen in permafrost near the village of Belaya Gora in north-eastern Siberia, the bird was discovered by local...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)NASA wants your help. No, really.From the outside, the agency may appear a monolith, but in reality, citizen scientists can play a substantial role -- perhaps none more so than in the ongoing Juno mission.Since 2016, the Juno spacecraft has circled...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)A heartbroken community will come together Friday to say goodbye to a girl who was abducted and killed by a neighbor in South Carolina. The memorial service for Faye Marie Swetlik, 6, will be Friday at 7 p.m. at Trinity Baptist Church in Cayce....

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Protesters attacked a convoy of buses carrying Ukrainian citizens and other nationals evacuated from the Chinese city of Wuhan, injuring nine police officers and one civilian Thursday.As global fears and misconceptions spread about the coronavirus...

Posted Friday, 21 February 2020 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Weeks after the novel coronavirus crisis began in December, there is still widespread confusion over the exact number of cases reported in China and whether the epidemic is finally stabilizing at the outbreak's epicenter of Hubei province. On...