A legacy of failure: Theresa May was a disaster as Prime Minister

Posted Friday, 24 May 2019 ‐ CNN

Luke McGee is a senior producer at CNN based in London.London (CNN)Brexit has destroyed another British Prime Minister.Three years after voters in the UK mandated their government to take Britain out of the European Union, Theresa May's failure to do so has finally caught up with her. "I have done my best," she said in an emotional statement on the steps of Downing Street. But as she admitted, it wasn't enough.It always seems to end like this for leaders of May's Conservative Party, divided for years over Britain's relationship with the European Union. Her predecessor, David Cameron, quit the morning after 52% of the UK voted to leave the EU, having presided over his own political miscalculation. Under her leadership, the governing Conservative Party has gone from being seen as the natural party of government to the exploding clown car of politics. Worse than being unable to govern, the Conservative's mishandling of Brexit has led to the public humiliation of the UK's oldest and most successful political party suffering electoral losses to a party that didn't exist six weeks ago. May had previously said that she would stand down if her deal was approved, letting someone else take control of the next stage of Brexit. It turns out that top-to-bottom rejection of her deal and her leadership from pretty much everyone involved in politics would also do the trick. May's legacy will be defined by failures, public humiliations and catastrophic political miscalculations. Some of these were out of her hands. Some were the result of poor advice from those she chose to surround herself with. Some were because of the unprecedented political crisis that would come to dominate her time in Downing Street.But much of it was her own fault. Many of her decisions had a directly negative impact on her ability to lead. The problem for May wasn't just that British politics has been deadlocked for the best part of three years, but that she repeatedly engineered ways to erode her own authority.By the time she accepted her number was up, she had lost the confidence of MPs, members of her own party and even her own Cabinet.Before taking the job, May had long been tipped for high office. In 2002, while serving as chair of the Conservative Party, May addressed the faithful at their annual party conference. At the time, the conservatives had been out of power for five years. Tony Blair had successfully won over some traditional conservative voters and the party had an image problem. This also meant it had an electoral problem: "Our base is too narrow and so, occasionally, are our sympathies. You know what some people call us - the nasty party," May said.This speech went down a storm and paved the way for a new era. In 2005, the party would elect David Cameron as leader. Cameron knew the importance of May's support, so made her a close ally and, along with other Tory moderates, oversaw a sweeping modernization of the party. It would come to be a party that believed in helping communities, the "Big Society", and would eventually be the party that legalized gay marriage in the UK.Cameron became Prime Minister in 2010, albeit as leader of a coalition government with the centre left Liberal Democrats. Again, knowing May's importance and her appeal to the more conservative members of the party's base, he made her Home Secretary.May was always considered one of the toughest members of Cameron's Cabinet. As Home Secretary, she accused the Police Federation -- the association that represents rank-and-file police officers in the UK -- of "crying wolf" over budget cuts. She presided over a policy of creating a "hostile environment" for illegal immigrants. She even took on the EU on matters ranging from immigration to the deportation of high-profile terrorists. She was a force to be reckoned with and seen as one of the cornerstones of conservatism in a coalition compromised by liberals.It was a shock to some when in 2016, May announced that she would be backing David Cameron's Remain campaign. But her decision to do so, it turned out, was a masterstroke in triangulation. When Cameron resigned in the wake of the result of the Brexit referendum, May was seen as a safe pair of hands. She backed Remain, but her track record in the Home Office meant she was tough enough to stand up to the EU. She was the best candidate to unite two sides of the Conservative Party that voted for different things. At least that was the theory.However, from the moment she became Prime Minister, she began alienating people whose loyalty she would later regret not being able to depend upon.In the months that followed May's ascension to the top job, her Brexit position hardened. Rather reach across the political divide within her own party, the Prime Minister's embrace of Brexit was similar to that of the evangelism of a born-again Christian. Her new, ardent Brexiteer persona won her support on her own backbenches and in the Brexit-supporting media. The Daily Mail, an anti-EU newspaper, declared that May would "crush the saboteurs" who sought to frustrate Brexit.While her new position as the defender of Brexit Britain won her some friends, it put off those who wanted a softer Brexit or no Brexit at all. But May and her advisors didn't seem to realize how she was seen outside of the Brexit bubble.This new confidence led to May and her inner circle making their first catastrophic mistake. In June 2017, despite having made little progress on Brexit plans, May held a snap election, designed to increase her majority of 13 to something north of 100.Her plan backfired. A limp election campaign in which May seldom appeared in public -- and seemed hellbent on avoiding any members of it -- made her look out of touch and power-hungry.The opposition Labour Party took advantage. It managed to position itself not only as the more pro-Europe option, but its leader, Jeremy Corbyn, seemed more human. The result was the Conservatives winning the election, but Theresa May having her majority taken from her.From this point on, May couldn't catch a break. Less than a week after her unnecessary humiliation, Britain was struck by tragedy. The fire that ripped through Grenfell Tower in London left 72 people dead and a community rocked.May's response to this was widely criticized. She visited the site, but didn't meet with any of the survivors. It made her look cold and unsympathetic. While no one seeks to use a disaster like this for political gain, May's woes were compounded by images Jeremy Corbyn hugging survivors. Even the Queen put on a better show.Worse for May was that the Grenfell tragedy came to be viewed by many as the result of Conservative policies under David Cameron. Whether this was factually true or not didn't matter: Labour was on the side of the people; May simply didn't care.Less than a week after Grenfell, the UK was struggling with another tragedy. A British man with a history of violence and fascination with anti-Islam ideas drove a van into a crowd of Muslims, leaving the Finsbury Park Mosque in London after evening prayers. When May visited the scene of the attack, she was heckled by bystanders. The political atmosphere in the country was becoming febrile.May's authority was under increasing pressure. Her election failure had forced her to sack her political advisors and enter into a supply and confidence agreement with the Northern Irish Democratic Unionist Party, who in theory prop up her minority government. More on this later.May was forced to face the music at the annual conference of her Conservative Party in October 2017. Her now infamous speech, in which she suffered a coughing fit, was confronted by a stage invader who handed her a P45 (the UK equivalent of a pink slip) was topped off with the set falling apart behind her. And it came after days of mutiny from within her party, which numerous of the not-so-faithful publicly saying that it was time for May to go.At this point, one might be tempted to feel sorry for the PM. But hold on a second. Sure, she can't help a cough, a stage invader or bad set design. It's very unlucky. But she could have avoided her fate of having to stand before a room of people utterly sick of her.It was around this time that her Brexit plan started to go badly. Meeting after meeting in Brussels resulted in EU officials and leaders publicly admonishing the UK's Brexit negotiators.Over time, May's Brexit position softened as talks with the EU became friendlier and common ground was reached. But this is where May made another political error. While talks had been going well in Brussels, May's Brexit plan was still a secret to many in London. And while it's all well and good the Government and EU officials agreeing on this and that, whether or not the British public or political class would accept it is another thing.That failure to include a House of Commons she knew to be divided resulted in a deal being agreed that parliament would hate. And that's why it kept failing.This has created problems for May both in London and on the continent. Over time, EU leaders have simply stopped believing anything she said. The same goes for Brexiteers, who once saw her as their champion. The low point of trust in her own party perhaps came at a meeting of hardline Brexiteers last year, when members of her own party were heard chanting "Theresa the appeaser," a reference to former Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain, infamous for striking a deal with Adolf Hitler in 1938.Outside of Brexit, her time in the Home Office came back to haunt her more than once. First, the Windrush scandal. Her "hostile environment" policy created legislation which required immigrants to prove their immigrant status by providing paperwork when trying to do things like rent a flat.Unintentionally, this hit a generation of immigrants from the Caribbean, who came to the UK in the post-war years to make up for a shortage in the workforce. Many of them were without paperwork and suddenly faced the threat of deportation, despite having lived in the country for decades.The public outrage that followed once again made May look out of touch and unsympathetic. It also meant one of her arch-loyalists, Amber Rudd, was forced to quit as Home Secretary.Other decisions made during her earlier period in Cameron's government have caused problems for May. The UK's knife crime crisis has been blamed by many on police cuts she implemented. While the veracity of this claim is unclear, defending a policy of cutting police funding while parents are seeing their children murdered is not a good look.But it was her mishandling of Brexit and poor political decisions that made governing impossible for May.As the Brexit endgame drew closer, she was visibly losing the support of her Cabinet. After a meeting at the Prime Minister's country retreat, Chequers, in which she outlined the latest Brexit policy position, she lost two important ministers. Boris Johnson, her Foreign Secretary and the most prominent Conservative Brexiteer, and David Davis, her Brexit Secretary, decided they'd had enough.

Other articles published by CNN

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)The 2020 Democratic candidates for president are everywhere. We know their policies. We know their playlists. But do we know their dogs? Donald Trump eschewed tradition when he entered the White House pet-less. The last pups to live in the Oval...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Some might say Golden State Warriors star Steph Curry has already "made it." Now he's using his success to help future generations of African-Americans do the same.The three-time NBA champion has announced he will fund the first six years of a new...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Thirty years ago, NASA's Voyager 2 mission flew by Neptune, capturing the first close-up images of the blue gas giant. Before this, the eighth planet in our solar system was only known as a fuzzy dot in the distance. And the end of Voyager 2's...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)The US is warning Iran it's taking Tehran's threats seriously and will hold it accountable if it compromises the safety of any American.The comments came in a tweet from US State Department spokeswoman Morgan Ortagus on Saturday, after Iran...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)The Cherokee Nation announced Thursday that it intends to appoint a delegate to the US House of Representatives, asserting for the first time a right promised to the tribe in a nearly 200-year-old treaty with the federal government.It was a historic ...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

Houston, Texas (CNN)Two days after Hurricane Harvey made landfall in Texas in August 2017, as historic rainfall submerged parts of Houston, the Army Corps of Engineers released water from two reservoirs into a river running through one of the country's...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)United Airlines is suspending daily service from Chicago's O'Hare International Airport to Hong Kong starting next month, the company confirmed to CNN Saturday. "While our service between the United States and HKG (Hong Kong) remains a vital part of ...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

Moscow (CNN)It's been a heady summer for Russia's embattled political opposition. On August 10, as many as 50,000 people rallied in Moscow calling for fair local elections, the biggest protests seen in the capital since early 2012. Now opposition leaders ...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)British Prime Minister Boris Johnson told reporters Saturday that he will ask US President Donald Trump not to escalate the trade war with China. Johnson made the statements after arriving for the G7 summit in the southwestern French city of...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Quarterback Andrew Luck, the first pick in the 2012 NFL draft and a four-time Pro Bowl selection, is retiring, the Indianapolis Colts player said Saturday night."This is not an easy decision," he told reporters.Injuries have kept Luck, 29, from...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Russia launched two ballistic missiles from nuclear-powered submarines in the Arctic Ocean and the Barents Sea on Saturday, according to a tweet from the Russian Ministry of Defense. Described as a successful test launch, the missiles were part of...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)On Friday, most of the service members of the Air Force's 20th Fighter Wing at Shaw Air Force base in South Carolina will get a needed extra day off. The day off comes after three airmen have died by suicide since May, according to media reports....

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

Julian Zelizer is a professor of history and public affairs at Princeton University, and author, with Kevin Kruse, of the new book "Fault Lines: A History of the United States Since 1974." Follow him on Twitter at @julianzelizer. The opinions expressed...

Posted Sunday, 25 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Disney teased fans on Saturday with a sneak peek at Cruella de Vil's new punk rock look -- which left fans a little confused.Emma Stone plays the evil dog-napper in the upcoming movie "Cruella," an origin story of the classic "101 Dalmatians."In the ...

Posted Saturday, 24 August 2019 ‐ CNN

(CNN)Windmills and solar panels may soon be keeping the lights on in the reptile house, and throughout the Detroit Zoo.The zoo, located in Detroit's suburb of Royal Oak, says it's shifting to being powered entirely by renewable energy."We are announcing...